Add de-anthropocentric Mass Number revision

0-Core-Formalism/otom/docs/mass_numbers_deanthropocentric_revision.md

@@ -0,0 +1,246 @@
+---
+project: OTOM
+domain: axis-04-formalization
+type: DoctrineRevision
+settlement: FORMING
+authority: registry
+route_signature: otom/axis-04-formalization/doctrinerevision/mass-numbers-deanthropocentric/v0
+claim_state: BEAUTIFUL_PROVISIONAL
+---
+
+# Mass Numbers: De-anthropocentric Revision
+
+## Revision trigger
+
+Earlier Mass Number language leaked human egocentrism by treating human natural
+language, especially English-facing semantic compression, as the implicit center
+of semantic mass.
+
+That framing is too narrow.
+
+Mass Numbers must be revised around decoder-relative recoverability across many
+communication regimes:
+
+- human languages and scripts
+- animal communication systems
+- mathematical and chemical notation
+- machine protocols and bytecode
+- physical signal regimes
+- spatial / visual / goxel witnesses
+- color, spectral, acoustic, chemical, tactile, and field-coded signals
+
+## Corrected doctrine
+
+```text
+SemanticMass is the meaning-bearing object.
+MassNumber is the admissibility / recoverability receipt projected from it.
+```
+
+Mass Number does not ask whether a signal is human language.
+It asks:
+
+```text
+Given a signal S, decoder D, context C, and receiver regime R,
+how much actionable / recoverable structure survives,
+and what residual ambiguity or risk remains?
+```
+
+## Old error
+
+```text
+MassNumber ≈ admissible reduction / residual risk
+```
+
+This is useful, but it is only the engineering shadow.
+It is not the full semantic object.
+
+## Revised layer split
+
+| Layer | Object | Role |
+|---|---|---|
+| Ontological / semantic | `SemanticMass` | meaning-bearing load under a decoder |
+| Engineering / gate | `MassNumber` | admissibility receipt derived from semantic load and residual risk |
+| Evidence / promotion | receipts | proof, benchmark, adversarial trial, or measurement support |
+| Hardware / emission | static binary / Verilog | compiled projection of accepted structures |
+
+## De-anthropocentric principle
+
+```text
+No language, species, script, modality, or sensorium is the privileged center.
+```
+
+A human sentence, a Chinese character, a Korean honorific particle, a whale song,
+a bee waggle vector, an ant pheromone trail, a bat click train, a cephalopod skin
+pattern, a mathematical formula, and a machine opcode can all be SemanticCarriers
+if they bind recoverable state under a decoder.
+
+## Communication regime, not language-only
+
+A communication regime is any system with:
+
+```text
+signal form
+receiver / decoder
+context
+recoverable state
+residual ambiguity
+observable or formal response
+```
+
+Human languages are one family of regimes.
+Animal communication systems are another.
+Formal notation and machine protocols are others.
+
+## Revised formula family
+
+The human-centric version:
+
+```text
+M_sem = semantic payload / decoder residual ambiguity
+```
+
+The de-anthropocentric version:
+
+```text
+M_regime(S, D, C, R) =
+  recoverable structure(S, D, C, R)
+  /
+  signal cost + decoder cost + context cost + residual ambiguity + response risk
+```
+
+Where:
+
+- `S` = signal or symbolic packet
+- `D` = decoder
+- `C` = context / environment
+- `R` = receiver or runtime regime
+
+For theorem work, avoid division and use bounded comparisons:
+
+```text
+recoverable_structure <= threshold * guarded_residual_cost
+```
+
+## Human regime channels
+
+| Channel | Examples | Semantic mass contribution |
+|---|---|---|
+| Glyphic | Han characters, Egyptian determinatives, Mayan glyphs | visual-symbol semantic packing |
+| Morphological | Korean, Turkish, Inuktitut, Finnish | bound relation/state/action packing |
+| Root-template | Arabic, Hebrew | generative semantic family compression |
+| Evidential | Quechua, Aymara, Tibetan-like evidential systems | receipt / source-of-knowledge marking |
+| Relational | Korean, Georgian, Bantu agreement, honorifics | agent/social/role binding |
+| Tonal/prosodic | Yoruba, Mandarin, Vietnamese, Thai | phase-like semantic distinction |
+| Formal | Greek, Sanskrit, Latin, mathematics | stable abstract/theorem naming |
+
+## Animal / biosemiotic regime channels
+
+| Channel | Examples | Semantic mass contribution |
+|---|---|---|
+| Acoustic | birdsong, whale song, frog calls, primate calls | identity, territory, alarm, mating, group coordination |
+| Echolocation/probe | bats, dolphins | spatial field interrogation and object-state coupling |
+| Chemical | ants, bees, mammals, pheromone trails | path, colony state, reproductive status, alarm |
+| Spatial/vector | bee waggle dance, sign-like gesture systems | direction, distance, location, action target |
+| Visual/display | cephalopods, birds, fish, cuttlefish, skin patterns | color/state/threat/camouflage/intent signaling |
+| Electric/field | weakly electric fish | identity, courtship, spatial sensing, local field state |
+| Tactile/vibrational | insects, spiders, elephants via ground coupling | substrate-coded signal and long-range state transfer |
+
+## New Mass Number classes
+
+```text
+MN-HUM-G   Human glyphic mass
+MN-HUM-M   Human morphological mass
+MN-HUM-R   Human relational mass
+MN-HUM-E   Human evidential mass
+MN-HUM-T   Human tonal/prosodic mass
+MN-HUM-F   Human formal-symbolic mass
+
+MN-BIO-A   Bioacoustic mass
+MN-BIO-E   Echolocation/probe mass
+MN-BIO-C   Chemical trail mass
+MN-BIO-S   Spatial/vector biological mass
+MN-BIO-D   Display/color biological mass
+MN-BIO-V   Tactile/vibrational mass
+MN-BIO-R   Receiver-response mass
+
+MN-MACH-P  Machine protocol mass
+MN-MACH-O  Opcode / bytecode mass
+MN-MATH-F  Formal mathematical mass
+MN-PHYS-W  Wave/spectral physical mass
+MN-VIS-G   Goxel / visual witness mass
+```
+
+## GCCL revision
+
+GCCL symbol swapping must not optimize only byte density or human readability.
+
+A swap is admissible only if the receiving decoder preserves the relevant
+regime invariant:
+
+```text
+AllowedSwap(A, B, D_A, D_B, C, R) iff
+  invariant_cluster(A) = invariant_cluster(B)
+  and semantic_mass(B, D_B, C, R) >= semantic_mass(A, D_A, C, R) - epsilon
+  and derived_mass_number(B) passes the admissibility gate
+```
+
+This prevents the stack from collapsing non-human signal systems into English
+paraphrases and losing the actual invariant.
+
+## FAMM revision
+
+FAMM routing should route by communication regime and receiver effect, not only
+by human semantic tags.
+
+```text
+signal -> decoder -> receiver state change -> residual -> route
+```
+
+For animal communication, the receiver-response leg is central.
+For mathematical notation, proof preservation is central.
+For machine protocols, runtime state transition is central.
+For visual/goxel witnesses, spatial binding is central.
+
+## Evidence discipline
+
+Allowed now:
+
+1. Treat Mass Numbers as decoder-relative admissibility receipts.
+2. Treat human languages as one carrier family among many.
+3. Treat animal communication as biosemiotic regimes with measurable response invariants.
+4. Project SemanticMass into MassNumber only through declared decoder/context assumptions.
+
+Blocked until evidence receipts:
+
+1. Claims that any one language or species is globally superior.
+2. Claims that animal communication is human-equivalent language.
+3. Claims of compression gain without corpus baselines.
+4. Claims of semantic preservation without reconstruction or receiver-response tests.
+5. Claims of physical equivalence without SI-grounded measurement.
+
+## Implementation implication
+
+Existing formal roles should be interpreted as follows:
+
+```text
+SemanticCarrier instance
+  -> describes a regime capable of carrying recoverable structure
+
+SemanticMass vector
+  -> scores invariant strength, binding, routing leverage, compression gain,
+     update resistance, turbulence cost, and collapse resistance
+
+MassNumber gate
+  -> receives projected admissible reduction and residual risk from the
+     SemanticMass / decoder analysis
+```
+
+The revision is therefore not a deletion of MassNumber.
+It is a demotion of MassNumber from semantic essence to admissibility receipt.
+
+## Next artifacts
+
+1. Add `CommunicationRegime` and `BioSignalRegime` structures.
+2. Add registry schemas for human language, animal communication, formal notation, and machine protocol carriers.
+3. Add a bridge module from `SemanticMass` to `MassNumber`.
+4. Mine corpora/databases to emit evidence receipts before promotion.