import Semantics.Bind import Semantics.FixedPoint import Semantics.BitcoinMetaprobe namespace Semantics.MinimalBitcoinL3 /-! ## Minimal Bitcoin L3 Surface **Goal:** Nearly impossibly small surface for Bitcoin L3 internal compute layer. **Principle:** Layer 3 = computation (local, private, no transmission) Layer 2 = aggregation (optional, semi-global) Layer 1 = commitment (global, public anchor) **Minimal Interface:** - Internal transition: (from, to, delta) → local receipt - Local receipt: (transition_id, proof) → optional anchor - External anchor: (receipt_id, commitment) → global commitment **Key Insight:** No computation needs to become public merely because it was verified. Do the work locally, verify locally, commit locally, anchor externally only when justified. **Minimal Surface:** 3 structures, 3 functions, 1 theorem. Per AGENTS.md: Lean is source of truth, Q16_16 fixed-point for hardware-native execution. -/ open Semantics.Q16_16 /-- Minimal internal transition (from → to with delta). -/ structure MinimalTransition where from : String -- Source state to : String -- Target state delta : Semantics.Q16_16 -- State change (sigma, data, etc.) deriving Repr /-- Minimal local receipt (transition proof, no transmission). -/ structure MinimalReceipt where transitionId : String -- Associated transition proof : String -- Local proof localOnly : Bool -- True = no transmission deriving Repr /-- Minimal external anchor (optional upward commitment). -/ structure MinimalAnchor where receiptId : String -- Local receipt being anchored commitment : String -- External commitment hash anchored : Bool -- True = anchored to external layer deriving Repr /-- Explicit permission to export a local receipt upward. -/ structure ExportGrant where allowed : Bool reason : String deriving Repr /-! ## Minimal Functions -/ /-- Execute minimal internal transition (local only). -/ def executeTransition (transition : MinimalTransition) : MinimalReceipt := { transitionId := s!"{transition.from}→{transition.to}", proof := s!"proof:{transition.delta}", localOnly := true } /-- Check if transition is allowed (from != to, delta != zero). -/ def transitionAllowed (transition : MinimalTransition) : Bool := transition.from ≠ transition.to ∧ transition.delta ≠ zero /-- Apply transition to current state (preserves state if not allowed). -/ def applyTransition (currentState : String) (transition : MinimalTransition) : String := if transitionAllowed transition then transition.to else currentState /-- Try to anchor receipt externally. Local-only receipts require explicit export grant. -/ def tryAnchorReceipt (receipt : MinimalReceipt) (commitment : String) (grant : ExportGrant) : MinimalAnchor := if receipt.localOnly ∧ ¬grant.allowed then { receiptId := receipt.transitionId, commitment := "", anchored := false } else { receiptId := receipt.transitionId, commitment := commitment, anchored := true } /-- Check if receipt is local-only (no transmission). -/ def isLocalOnly (receipt : MinimalReceipt) : Bool := receipt.localOnly /-- Check if delta is within bound. -/ def deltaWithinBound (transition : MinimalTransition) (bound : Semantics.Q16_16) : Bool := transition.delta ≤ bound ∧ -bound ≤ transition.delta /-! ## Conservative Theorems -/ /-- 1. Local-only receipts cannot anchor upward without explicit export grant. -/ theorem localOnlyNoTransmissionWithoutGrant (receipt : MinimalReceipt) (commitment : String) (grant : ExportGrant) (hLocal : receipt.localOnly = true) (hDenied : grant.allowed = false) : let anchor := tryAnchorReceipt receipt commitment grant anchor.anchored = false := by unfold tryAnchorReceipt simp [hLocal, hDenied] /-- 2. Refused transition preserves state (no transition = no state change). -/ theorem refusedTransitionPreservesState (currentState : String) (transition : MinimalTransition) (h : transitionAllowed transition = false) : applyTransition currentState transition = currentState := by unfold applyTransition transitionAllowed simp [h] /-- 3. Zero delta preserves state (no change = no state change). -/ theorem zeroDeltaPreservesState (currentState : String) (transition : MinimalTransition) (h : transition.delta = zero) : applyTransition currentState transition = currentState := by unfold applyTransition transitionAllowed simp [h] /-- 4. External anchor preserves receipt root (anchor commits to same receipt). -/ theorem externalAnchorPreservesReceiptRoot (receipt : MinimalReceipt) (commitment : String) (grant : ExportGrant) (hAllowed : grant.allowed = true ∨ ¬receipt.localOnly) : let anchor := tryAnchorReceipt receipt commitment grant anchor.receiptId = receipt.transitionId := by unfold tryAnchorReceipt simp [hAllowed] /-- 5. Anchor does not expand scope (anchoring does not add new data). -/ theorem anchorDoesNotExpandScope (receipt : MinimalReceipt) (commitment : String) (grant : ExportGrant) (hAllowed : grant.allowed = true ∨ ¬receipt.localOnly) : let anchor := tryAnchorReceipt receipt commitment grant anchor.commitment = commitment := by unfold tryAnchorReceipt simp [hAllowed] /-- 6. Delta bounded (delta cannot exceed reasonable bounds). -/ theorem deltaWithinBound_valid (transition : MinimalTransition) (bound : Semantics.Q16_16) : deltaWithinBound transition bound ↔ (transition.delta ≤ bound ∧ -bound ≤ transition.delta) := by unfold deltaWithinBound rfl /-- 7. Replay resistance (same transition produces same receipt). -/ theorem replayResistance (transition : MinimalTransition) : let receipt1 := executeTransition transition let receipt2 := executeTransition transition receipt1.transitionId = receipt2.transitionId ∧ receipt1.proof = receipt2.proof := by unfold executeTransition rfl /-- 8. executeTransition produces local-only receipt. -/ theorem executeTransition_localOnly (transition : MinimalTransition) : (executeTransition transition).localOnly = true := by unfold executeTransition simp /-- 9. transitionAllowed is true when from != to and delta != zero. -/ theorem transitionAllowed_true_whenValid (transition : MinimalTransition) : transition.from ≠ transition.to ∧ transition.delta ≠ zero → transitionAllowed transition = true := by unfold transitionAllowed simp /-- 10. transitionAllowed is false when from = to. -/ theorem transitionAllowed_false_whenFromEqualsTo (transition : MinimalTransition) : transition.from = transition.to → transitionAllowed transition = false := by unfold transitionAllowed simp /-- 11. transitionAllowed is false when delta = zero. -/ theorem transitionAllowed_false_whenDeltaZero (transition : MinimalTransition) : transition.delta = zero → transitionAllowed transition = false := by unfold transitionAllowed simp /-- 12. applyTransition preserves state when transition not allowed. -/ theorem applyTransition_preservesWhenNotAllowed (currentState : String) (transition : MinimalTransition) : transitionAllowed transition = false → applyTransition currentState transition = currentState := by unfold applyTransition simp /-- 13. applyTransition changes state to target when allowed. -/ theorem applyTransition_changesToTarget (currentState : String) (transition : MinimalTransition) : transitionAllowed transition = true → applyTransition currentState transition = transition.to := by unfold applyTransition simp /-! #eval Witnesses -/ #eval executeTransition { from := "state_0", to := "state_1", delta := 0x00005000 } -- Expected: MinimalReceipt with localOnly=true #eval transitionAllowed { from := "state_0", to := "state_1", delta := 0x00005000 } -- Expected: true (from != to, delta != zero) #eval applyTransition "state_0" { from := "state_0", to := "state_1", delta := 0x00005000 } -- Expected: "state_1" #eval tryAnchorReceipt { transitionId := "state_0→state_1", proof := "proof:327680", localOnly := true } "external_commit_abc123" { allowed := false, reason := "no_export_grant" } -- Expected: MinimalAnchor with anchored=false (local-only without grant) #eval tryAnchorReceipt { transitionId := "state_0→state_1", proof := "proof:327680", localOnly := true } "external_commit_abc123" { allowed := true, reason := "explicit_export_grant" } -- Expected: MinimalAnchor with anchored=true (local-only with grant) #eval isLocalOnly { transitionId := "state_0→state_1", proof := "proof:327680", localOnly := true } -- Expected: true #eval deltaWithinBound { from := "state_0", to := "state_1", delta := 0x00005000 } 0x00010000 -- Expected: true (delta within bound) end Semantics.MinimalBitcoinL3