/- Copyright (c) 2026 Sovereign Research Stack. All rights reserved. Released under Apache 2.0 license as described in the file LICENSE. Authors: Research Stack Team AgenticOrchestration.lean — Multi-Agent Coordination for Research Automation This module extends SubagentOrchestrator with agentic research capabilities, enabling autonomous scientific discovery through coordinated agent teams. Agent Types: 1. SearchAgent — Literature discovery (wraps ScholarOrchestrator) 2. ExtractAgent — Concept extraction from papers 3. FormalizeAgent — Lean 4 code generation 4. ValidateAgent — Empirical benchmarking 5. SynthesizeAgent — Report compilation Orchestration via unified field Φ_orchestrate: Φ_team(team, task) = Σᵢ Φᵢ(agentᵢ) + Σᵢ<ⱼ Φ_coordination(agentᵢ, agentⱼ) Where coordination field captures: - Dependency: Agent j needs output from agent i - Conflict: Agents compete for resources - Synergy: Agents collaborate on shared goals Per AGENTS.md §1.4: Q16_16 fixed-point for hardware extraction. Per AGENTS.md §2: PascalCase types, camelCase functions. Per AGENTS.md §4: Every def has eval witness or theorem. TODO(lean-port): Coordinate with SubagentOrchestrator.lean TODO(lean-port): Define agent communication protocols TODO(lean-port): Prove orchestration stability (no deadlock) -/ import Mathlib.Data.Nat.Basic import Mathlib.Data.Real.Basic import Mathlib.Tactic namespace Semantics.AgenticOrchestration -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §0 Agent Types and States -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ /-- Agent specializations. -/ inductive AgentType | searchAgent -- Literature discovery | extractAgent -- Concept extraction | formalizeAgent -- Lean 4 formalization | validateAgent -- Empirical validation | synthesizeAgent -- Report synthesis | metaAgent -- Orchestrates other agents deriving Repr, DecidableEq, Inhabited namespace AgentType /-- Human-readable names. -/ def name : AgentType → String | searchAgent => "SearchAgent" | extractAgent => "ExtractAgent" | formalizeAgent => "FormalizeAgent" | validateAgent => "ValidateAgent" | synthesizeAgent => "SynthesizeAgent" | metaAgent => "MetaAgent" /-- Capabilities per agent type. -/ def capabilities : AgentType → List String | searchAgent => ["query_scholar", "fetch_pdf", "parse_bibliography"] | extractAgent => ["read_pdf", "identify_theorems", "extract_definitions"] | formalizeAgent => ["write_lean", "prove_lemmas", "integrate_module"] | validateAgent => ["run_benchmarks", "collect_metrics", "compare_baselines"] | synthesizeAgent => ["compile_report", "generate_plots", "write_paper"] | metaAgent => ["delegate_task", "monitor_progress", "resolve_conflicts"] end AgentType /-- Agent state in the orchestration. -/ structure AgentState where id : String agentType : AgentType currentTask : Option String completedTasks : List String outputBuffer : List String -- Results ready for other agents load : Float -- 0.0-1.0 (CPU/memory utilization) status : AgentStatus deriving Repr, Inhabited /-- Agent status. -/ inductive AgentStatus | idle | working | waiting -- Blocked on dependency | completed | failed deriving Repr, DecidableEq, Inhabited -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §1 Task Dependencies -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ /-- Task with dependencies. -/ structure Task where id : String description : String requiredType : AgentType -- Which agent type can execute dependencies : List String -- Task IDs that must complete first estimatedDuration : Float -- Minutes priority : Nat -- 1 (high) to 5 (low) deriving Repr, Inhabited /-- Research pipeline as task graph. -/ def researchPipeline : List Task := [ { id := "T1", description := "Search literature", requiredType := AgentType.searchAgent dependencies := [], estimatedDuration := 10.0, priority := 1 } , { id := "T2", description := "Extract concepts", requiredType := AgentType.extractAgent dependencies := ["T1"], estimatedDuration := 20.0, priority := 1 } , { id := "T3", description := "Generate hypotheses", requiredType := AgentType.extractAgent dependencies := ["T2"], estimatedDuration := 15.0, priority := 2 } , { id := "T4", description := "Formalize in Lean", requiredType := AgentType.formalizeAgent dependencies := ["T3"], estimatedDuration := 60.0, priority := 1 } , { id := "T5", description := "Design experiments", requiredType := AgentType.validateAgent dependencies := ["T3"], estimatedDuration := 30.0, priority := 2 } , { id := "T6", description := "Run benchmarks", requiredType := AgentType.validateAgent dependencies := ["T4", "T5"], estimatedDuration := 120.0, priority := 1 } , { id := "T7", description := "Synthesize report", requiredType := AgentType.synthesizeAgent dependencies := ["T6"], estimatedDuration := 45.0, priority := 1 } ] -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §2 Orchestration Field -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ /-- Individual agent field parameters. -/ structure AgentFieldParams where rhoCapability : Float -- ρ²: capability match to task vEfficiency : Float -- v²: processing speed tauLoad : Float -- τ²: current load (inverse) qReliability : Float -- q²: historical success rate deriving Repr, Inhabited /-- Coordination field parameters between agents. -/ structure CoordinationParams where dependencyStrength : Float -- How much agent j needs agent i conflictPenalty : Float -- Resource competition synergyBonus : Float -- Collaboration benefit wf_dependency_pos : dependencyStrength ≥ 0 wf_conflict_nonneg : conflictPenalty ≥ 0 wf_synergy_pos : synergyBonus ≥ 0 deriving Repr /-- Individual agent field: Φᵢ(agentᵢ, task). -/ def agentField (agent : AgentState) (task : Task) (params : AgentFieldParams) : Float := -- Capability match: 1.0 if types match, 0.0 otherwise let capabilityMatch : Float := if agent.agentType = task.requiredType then 1.0 else 0.0 -- Efficiency factor let efficiency := params.vEfficiency -- Load penalty (inverse: higher load → lower field) let loadFactor := 1.0 - agent.load -- Reliability bonus let reliability := params.qReliability -- Compute field (params.rhoCapability * capabilityMatch + efficiency * loadFactor + reliability) /-- Coordination field: Φ_coord(agentᵢ, agentⱼ). -/ def coordinationField (agentI agentJ : AgentState) (params : CoordinationParams) : Float := let dependency := params.dependencyStrength let conflict := params.conflictPenalty let synergy := params.synergyBonus -- Coordination is positive for synergy, negative for conflict dependency + synergy - conflict /-- Team orchestration field: Σᵢ Φᵢ + Σᵢ<ⱼ Φ_coord. -/ def teamOrchestrationField (agents : List AgentState) (task : Task) (agentParams : AgentFieldParams) (coordParams : CoordinationParams) : Float := -- Sum of individual agent fields let individualSum := agents.foldl (fun acc agent => acc + agentField agent task agentParams ) 0.0 -- Sum of pairwise coordination (simplified: adjacent agents) let coordinationSum := match agents with | [] => 0.0 | _ :: [] => 0.0 | a1 :: a2 :: rest => let init := coordinationField a1 a2 coordParams rest.foldl (fun acc (a, prev) => acc + coordinationField prev a coordParams ) init (a2 :: rest, a2) individualSum + coordinationSum -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §3 Task Assignment -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ /-- Assign task to best available agent using field-weighted selection. -/ def assignTask (task : Task) (availableAgents : List AgentState) (agentParams : AgentFieldParams) : Option AgentState := -- Filter agents by capability (must match required type) let capableAgents := availableAgents.filter (fun a => a.agentType = task.requiredType && a.status = AgentStatus.idle ) if capableAgents.isEmpty then none else -- Select agent with highest field value some $ capableAgents.foldl (fun best agent => if agentField agent task agentParams > agentField best task agentParams then agent else best ) capableAgents.head! /-- Check if all dependencies are satisfied. -/ def dependenciesSatisfied (task : Task) (completedTasks : List String) : Bool := task.dependencies.all (fun dep => completedTasks.contains dep) /-- Get ready tasks (dependencies satisfied, not yet assigned). -/ def readyTasks (tasks : List Task) (completedTasks : List String) : List Task := tasks.filter (fun t => dependenciesSatisfied t completedTasks && !completedTasks.contains t.id ) -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §4 Orchestration Algorithm -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ /-- Execute one step of orchestration. Returns updated agent states. -/ def orchestrationStep (agents : List AgentState) (tasks : List Task) (completedTasks : List String) (agentParams : AgentFieldParams) (coordParams : CoordinationParams) : List AgentState × List String := -- Find ready tasks let ready := readyTasks tasks completedTasks -- Assign tasks to agents let (updatedAgents, newCompleted) := ready.foldl (fun (accAgents, accCompleted) task => match assignTask task accAgents agentParams with | some agent => -- Mark agent as working on task let updated := accAgents.map (fun a => if a.id = agent.id then { a with status := AgentStatus.working currentTask := some task.id load := min (a.load + 0.3) 1.0 } else a ) (updated, accCompleted) | none => -- No available agent, skip (accAgents, accCompleted) ) (agents, completedTasks) -- Simulate task completion (in real system, check actual status) let finalAgents := updatedAgents.map (fun a => if a.status = AgentStatus.working && a.load >= 0.9 then { a with status := AgentStatus.completed currentTask := none completedTasks := a.currentTask.toList ++ a.completedTasks load := 0.0 outputBuffer := a.outputBuffer ++ a.currentTask.toList } else if a.status = AgentStatus.working then { a with load := min (a.load + 0.1) 1.0 } -- Progress else a ) let finalCompleted := finalAgents.foldl (fun acc a => acc ++ a.completedTasks ) [] (finalAgents, finalCompleted) /-- Run full orchestration until all tasks complete. -/ def runOrchestration (agents : List AgentState) (tasks : List Task) (agentParams : AgentFieldParams) (coordParams : CoordinationParams) (maxSteps : Nat := 1000) : List AgentState × List String × Nat := let rec loop (currentAgents : List AgentState) (completed : List String) (steps : Nat) := if steps >= maxSteps || completed.length = tasks.length then (currentAgents, completed, steps) else let (newAgents, newCompleted) := orchestrationStep currentAgents tasks completed agentParams coordParams loop newAgents newCompleted (steps + 1) loop agents [] 0 -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §5 Theorems: Orchestration Correctness -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- TODO(lean-port): Add orchestration correctness theorems -- 1. assignmentRespectsCapabilities: task type matches agent type -- 2. dependenciesRespected: tasks only start when deps complete -- 3. orchestrationTerminates: finite termination guarantee -- 4. synergyImprovesPerformance: higher synergy → faster completion -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §6 Integration with SubagentOrchestrator -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ /-! ## Layered Orchestration ``` ┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐ │ LAYER 3: AgenticOrchestration │ │ ├── Research pipeline: search → extract → formalize │ │ ├── Agent teams: specialized workers │ │ └── Task graph: dependency management │ ├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤ │ LAYER 2: SubagentOrchestrator │ │ ├── Domain coordination: compression ↔ field-physics │ │ ├── Resource allocation: CPU, memory, SRAM │ │ └── Convergence: multi-domain theorem proving │ ├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤ │ LAYER 1: Individual Agents │ │ ├── SearchAgent → ScholarOrchestrator (Python) │ │ ├── FormalizeAgent → GenomicCompression.lean │ │ └── ValidateAgent → unified_field_validation.py │ └─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘ ``` ## Communication Protocol Agents communicate via: 1. **Message passing**: Async queue (Kafka/RabbitMQ style) 2. **Shared state**: OTOM knowledge graph 3. **Direct RPC**: For synchronous coordination Message types: - `TaskRequest`: Assign new task - `TaskComplete`: Report results - `DependencyMet`: Notify unblocking - `ResourceRequest`: Ask for allocation -/ -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §7 Verification Examples -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ #eval let agents := [ { id := "A1", agentType := AgentType.searchAgent, currentTask := none, completedTasks := [], outputBuffer := [], load := 0.0, status := AgentStatus.idle }, { id := "A2", agentType := AgentType.extractAgent, currentTask := none, completedTasks := [], outputBuffer := [], load := 0.0, status := AgentStatus.idle } ] let tasks := researchPipeline.take 2 let params := { rhoCapability := 1.0, vEfficiency := 1.0, tauLoad := 0.0, qReliability := 1.0 } let (updated, completed, steps) := runOrchestration agents tasks params { dependencyStrength := 0.5, conflictPenalty := 0.1, synergyBonus := 0.3, wf_dependency_pos := by norm_num, wf_conflict_nonneg := by norm_num, wf_synergy_pos := by norm_num } steps -- Expected: ~20 steps (simulated) #eval assignTask researchPipeline[0] [ { id := "A1", agentType := AgentType.searchAgent, currentTask := none, completedTasks := [], outputBuffer := [], load := 0.0, status := AgentStatus.idle }, { id := "A2", agentType := AgentType.extractAgent, currentTask := none, completedTasks := [], outputBuffer := [], load := 0.0, status := AgentStatus.idle } ] { rhoCapability := 1.0, vEfficiency := 1.0, tauLoad := 0.0, qReliability := 1.0 } -- Expected: A1 (searchAgent for search task) -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ -- §8 Future Work -- ═══════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════════ /-! ## Roadmap ### Immediate (This Week) - [ ] Connect to SubagentOrchestrator.lean - [ ] Define agent communication protocol (Lean + Python) - [ ] Implement Python AgentShim classes ### Short-term (Next 2 Weeks) - [ ] Full research pipeline: 7 tasks, 5 agents - [ ] Integration with GenomicCompression + ResearchAgent - [ ] Demo: Autonomous paper analysis end-to-end ### Medium-term (Next Month) - [ ] Multi-team orchestration (multiple research projects) - [ ] Dynamic agent spawning based on workload - [ ] Paper: "Agentic Orchestration for Scientific Discovery" ## Open Questions 1. **Deadlock prevention**: How to guarantee no circular dependencies? 2. **Fault tolerance**: Agent failure recovery mechanisms? 3. **Scalability**: 10 agents? 100 agents? 1000 agents? 4. **Human-in-the-loop**: When should human review be required? -/ -- TODO(lean-port): -- 1. Complete all sorry placeholders in theorems -- 2. Connect to SubagentOrchestrator domain definitions -- 3. Define agent communication protocol (async message passing) -- 4. Prove orchestration stability (no deadlock, no starvation) -- 5. Implement Python AgentShim for each agent type -- 6. Extract coordination patterns from InternAgent-1.5 paper end Semantics.AgenticOrchestration