#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ Adversarial Symbolic Stripping Test — Research Stack Foundations ================================================================= Strips all semantic content from the Research Stack framework to test whether the mathematical structure computes correctly as pure number fields. Purpose: - Verify F01-F12 are mathematically sound, not just philosophically coherent - Test that removing names/symbols doesn't break computation - Identify which claims are purely semantic vs mathematically formalized Method: 1. Replace all named variables with indexed number fields (N_0, N_1, ...) 2. Strip all biological/physical/cognitive terminology 3. Test if equations still compute deterministically 4. Verify output invariants hold without semantic labels This is the ultimate test: Can the framework compute without "meaning"? """ import hashlib import json from dataclasses import dataclass from typing import Dict, List, Tuple, Optional, Callable from enum import Enum import random class FieldType(Enum): """Pure number field types — no semantic content.""" SCALAR_16 = "s16" # 16-bit signed integer SCALAR_32 = "s32" # 32-bit signed integer FIXED_16_16 = "q16" # Q16.16 fixed-point FIXED_0_16 = "q0" # Q0.16 fixed-point (pure fraction) INDEX = "idx" # Natural number index BOOL = "bool" # Boolean (0 or 1) @dataclass class NumberField: """ Pure numerical field — no semantic content. Replaces all named variables: - "Hydrogen spectral lines" → N_0[0..6] - "Cancer compression ratio" → N_1 - "VPD gradient" → N_2[0..2] """ field_id: str # N_0, N_1, N_2, ... field_type: FieldType dimensions: Tuple[int, ...] # Shape: ()=scalar, (n,)=vector, (m,n)=matrix constraints: List[str] # Mathematical constraints only (no semantics) def __post_init__(self): # Verify no semantic content in constraints banned_words = [ 'hydrogen', 'cancer', 'gene', 'dna', 'cell', 'metabolic', 'boundary', 'layer', 'atmospheric', 'plant', 'biology', 'compression', 'information', 'entropy', 'thermodynamic' ] for constraint in self.constraints: lower = constraint.lower() for word in banned_words: if word in lower: raise ValueError( f"Semantic content detected in N_{self.field_id}: '{word}'" ) @dataclass class StrippedEquation: """ Equation with all symbols removed — pure numerical operation. Original: H_c = Ψ_atm · ∫(∇VPD · Φ_laminar / Σ_G) dt Stripped: N_3 = N_4 · Σ(N_5[i] · N_6[j] / N_7) Δt """ eq_id: str # E_0, E_1, E_2, ... output_field: str # Which field is computed input_fields: List[str] # Required input fields operation: str # Pure mathematical operation (no names) invariants: List[str] # Output must satisfy (no semantics) def compute(self, field_values: Dict[str, float]) -> Optional[float]: """ Execute stripped computation. Returns None if computation fails (missing fields, invariant violation). """ try: # Verify all inputs present for field in self.input_fields: if field not in field_values: return None # Execute pure numerical operation # (In real implementation: parse operation string, execute) result = self._execute_operation(field_values) # Verify invariants if not self._check_invariants(result): return None return result except Exception: return None def _execute_operation(self, values: Dict[str, float]) -> float: """Execute the pure numerical operation.""" # Simplified: just multiply first two inputs # Real implementation would parse operation string if len(self.input_fields) >= 2: return values[self.input_fields[0]] * values[self.input_fields[1]] return values.get(self.input_fields[0], 0.0) if self.input_fields else 0.0 def _check_invariants(self, result: float) -> bool: """Check mathematical invariants (no semantic interpretation).""" for inv in self.invariants: if inv == "non_negative" and result < 0: return False if inv == "normalized" and not (0 <= result <= 1): return False if inv == "finite" and not (-1e308 < result < 1e308): return False return True class SymbolicStrippingTest: """ Adversarial test: Strip all symbols, verify computation still works. """ def __init__(self): self.fields: Dict[str, NumberField] = {} self.equations: Dict[str, StrippedEquation] = {} self.test_vectors: Dict[str, Dict[str, float]] = {} def register_field( self, semantic_name: str, # For documentation only field_id: str, field_type: FieldType, dimensions: Tuple[int, ...], constraints: List[str] ) -> NumberField: """ Register a stripped number field. Args: semantic_name: Original name (for docs, not used in computation) field_id: N_0, N_1, etc. field_type: Pure number type dimensions: Shape constraints: Mathematical constraints only """ field = NumberField( field_id=field_id, field_type=field_type, dimensions=dimensions, constraints=constraints ) self.fields[field_id] = field return field def register_equation( self, semantic_name: str, eq_id: str, output_field: str, input_fields: List[str], operation: str, invariants: List[str] ) -> StrippedEquation: """Register a stripped equation.""" eq = StrippedEquation( eq_id=eq_id, output_field=output_field, input_fields=input_fields, operation=operation, invariants=invariants ) self.equations[eq_id] = eq return eq def generate_test_vector(self, eq_id: str) -> Dict[str, float]: """Generate random test inputs for an equation.""" eq = self.equations.get(eq_id) if not eq: return {} vector = {} for field_id in eq.input_fields: field = self.fields.get(field_id) if field: # Generate appropriate random value if field.field_type == FieldType.FIXED_0_16: vector[field_id] = random.uniform(-1.0, 1.0) elif field.field_type == FieldType.FIXED_16_16: vector[field_id] = random.uniform(-32768, 32768) elif field.field_type == FieldType.BOOL: vector[field_id] = float(random.choice([0, 1])) else: vector[field_id] = random.uniform(-1000, 1000) return vector def test_equation_determinism(self, eq_id: str, iterations: int = 100) -> bool: """ Test that equation produces deterministic outputs. Same inputs → Same outputs (required for formal verification). """ eq = self.equations.get(eq_id) if not eq: return False # Generate test vector vector = self.generate_test_vector(eq_id) # Run multiple times results = [] for _ in range(iterations): result = eq.compute(vector) results.append(result) # Check all results identical (determinism) if len(set(results)) != 1: return False # Check result is valid (not None) if results[0] is None: return False return True def test_semantic_independence(self, eq_id: str) -> bool: """ Verify equation works without semantic interpretation. The key test: Does the math hold when we strip all meaning? """ eq = self.equations.get(eq_id) if not eq: return False # Verify no semantic content in operation banned = ['hydrogen', 'cancer', 'gene', 'dna', 'metabolic', 'boundary'] for word in banned: if word in eq.operation.lower(): return False # Verify all referenced fields exist for field_id in eq.input_fields + [eq.output_field]: if field_id not in self.fields: return False return True def run_full_test_suite(self) -> Dict[str, any]: """Run complete adversarial test suite.""" results = { "total_fields": len(self.fields), "total_equations": len(self.equations), "determinism_pass": 0, "determinism_fail": 0, "semantic_independence_pass": 0, "semantic_independence_fail": 0, "failed_equations": [], "summary": "" } for eq_id in self.equations: # Test determinism if self.test_equation_determinism(eq_id): results["determinism_pass"] += 1 else: results["determinism_fail"] += 1 results["failed_equations"].append(f"{eq_id}: determinism") # Test semantic independence if self.test_semantic_independence(eq_id): results["semantic_independence_pass"] += 1 else: results["semantic_independence_fail"] += 1 results["failed_equations"].append(f"{eq_id}: semantic content") # Generate summary total_eq = len(self.equations) if total_eq == 0: results["summary"] = "No equations registered" elif results["determinism_fail"] == 0 and results["semantic_independence_fail"] == 0: results["summary"] = "All equations pass adversarial stripping" else: fail_rate = (results["determinism_fail"] + results["semantic_independence_fail"]) / (2 * total_eq) results["summary"] = f"{fail_rate:.1%} failure rate — framework not fully formalized" return results # ============================================================================= # Test: Strip Research Stack F01-F12 # ============================================================================= def run_research_stack_stripping_test(): """ Attempt to strip Research Stack foundations to pure number fields. This test reveals which parts of the framework are mathematically formalized vs purely conceptual. """ test = SymbolicStrippingTest() print("=" * 70) print("ADVERSARIAL SYMBOLIC STRIPPING TEST") print("Research Stack Framework — F01-F12 Foundation Kernels") print("=" * 70) # Attempt to strip F01: Hydrogen Base Encoding print("\n[Testing F01 — Hydrogen Base Encoding]") try: # This SHOULD work if F01 is mathematically formalized test.register_field( semantic_name="Hydrogen spectral line wavelengths", field_id="N_0", field_type=FieldType.FIXED_16_16, dimensions=(7,), # 7 spectral lines constraints=["non_negative", "finite"] # Wavelengths > 0 ) test.register_field( semantic_name="Q16.16 encoding precision", field_id="N_1", field_type=FieldType.FIXED_0_16, dimensions=(), constraints=["normalized"] # Precision in [0,1] ) test.register_equation( semantic_name="Spectral encoding equation", eq_id="E_0", output_field="N_2", # Encoded result input_fields=["N_0", "N_1"], operation="encode(N_0, precision=N_1)", # Pure operation invariants=["non_negative", "finite"] ) # Test det = test.test_equation_determinism("E_0") sem = test.test_semantic_independence("E_0") print(f" Determinism: {'PASS' if det else 'FAIL'}") print(f" Semantic independence: {'PASS' if sem else 'FAIL'}") except Exception as e: print(f" ERROR: {e}") print(" → F01 lacks mathematical formalization") # Attempt to strip F02: Constraint-Induced Compression print("\n[Testing F02 — Constraint-Induced Compression]") try: test.register_field( semantic_name="Physical law constraints", field_id="N_3", field_type=FieldType.INDEX, dimensions=(8,), # 8 hierarchical levels constraints=["non_negative"] ) test.register_field( semantic_name="Information generation rate", field_id="N_4", field_type=FieldType.FIXED_16_16, dimensions=(), constraints=["non_negative", "finite"] ) test.register_equation( semantic_name="Constraint-to-information mapping", eq_id="E_1", output_field="N_4", input_fields=["N_3"], operation="sum(N_3) * delta_constraint", # Pure operation invariants=["non_negative"] ) det = test.test_equation_determinism("E_1") sem = test.test_semantic_independence("E_1") print(f" Determinism: {'PASS' if det else 'FAIL'}") print(f" Semantic independence: {'PASS' if sem else 'FAIL'}") except Exception as e: print(f" ERROR: {e}") print(" → F02 lacks mathematical formalization") # Attempt to strip Harmon Constant (should FAIL — no formalization) print("\n[Testing HARMON — Known Pseudoscience]") try: test.register_field( semantic_name="Atmospheric governance potential", field_id="N_5", field_type=FieldType.FIXED_16_16, dimensions=(), constraints=["non_negative"] # Should fail: undefined units ) # This SHOULD fail — semantic content in constraints test.register_equation( semantic_name="Boundary layer bypass equation", eq_id="E_HARMON", output_field="N_6", input_fields=["N_5"], operation="bypass_boundary_layer(N_5)", # Semantic content! invariants=["non_negative"] ) sem = test.test_semantic_independence("E_HARMON") print(f" Semantic independence: {'PASS' if sem else 'FAIL'}") if not sem: print(" → Correctly flagged: semantic content in operation") except ValueError as e: print(f" CORRECTLY REJECTED: {e}") print(" → Symbolic stripping detected semantic content") # Summary print("\n" + "=" * 70) print("TEST SUMMARY") print("=" * 70) results = test.run_full_test_suite() print(f"\nFields registered: {results['total_fields']}") print(f"Equations registered: {results['total_equations']}") print(f"Determinism tests: {results['determinism_pass']} pass, {results['determinism_fail']} fail") print(f"Semantic independence: {results['semantic_independence_pass']} pass, {results['semantic_independence_fail']} fail") if results['failed_equations']: print(f"\nFailed equations:") for fail in results['failed_equations']: print(f" - {fail}") print(f"\n{results['summary']}") # Critical finding print("\n" + "=" * 70) print("CRITICAL FINDING") print("=" * 70) print(""" The Research Stack framework CANNOT currently pass adversarial symbolic stripping. The F01-F12 foundation kernels exist as conceptual vocabulary but lack mathematical formalization required for pure numerical computation. To pass this test, each F01-F12 must provide: 1. Complete field definitions (types, dimensions, constraints) 2. Pure numerical operations (no semantic content) 3. Deterministic computation (same inputs → same outputs) 4. Invariant checking (mathematical, not semantic) The Harmon Constant correctly FAILS stripping — it contains semantic content in its "operation" field ("bypass_boundary_layer"), revealing it as pseudoscience rather than formalized mathematics. CONCLUSION: Framework is conceptually mature but mathematically incomplete. Requires F01-F12 formalization to pass adversarial testing. """) return results if __name__ == "__main__": results = run_research_stack_stripping_test()