#!/usr/bin/env python3 """ Relay Validation Shim — Research Stack Integration ==================================================== Integrates kridaydave/Relay context validation with Research Stack framework to provide cryptographic provenance, rollback capability, and claim verification. Purpose: - Validate derivation chains for F01-F12 foundation equations - Detect circular references in empirical claims - Enforce budget constraints on speculative assertions - Maintain immutable ledger of framework evolution Usage: from relay_validation_shim import ResearchStackValidator validator = ResearchStackValidator( framework_version="2026-05-06", target_standard="6.5sigma" ) # Register a claim result = validator.register_claim( claim_id="F03-BindingHierarchy", claim_type="mathematical", content="8-level hierarchical compression", dependencies=["F01-HydrogenBase", "F02-ConstraintGeneration"], evidence_paths=[ "0-Core-Formalism/lean/Semantics/HierarchicalBinding.lean" ] ) # Validate claim chain if validator.validate_chain("F03-BindingHierarchy"): print("Claim validated — all dependencies resolved") else: print(f"Validation failed: {validator.get_failure_reason()}") """ import hashlib import json from datetime import datetime, timezone from dataclasses import dataclass, field from typing import Dict, List, Optional, Set, Tuple, Union from enum import Enum, auto from pathlib import Path class ClaimStatus(Enum): """Validation status for framework claims.""" PROPOSED = auto() DERIVED = auto() # Has mathematical derivation IMPLEMENTED = auto() # Has Lean formalization TESTED = auto() # Has empirical validation VALIDATED = auto() # Meets 6.5σ standard SUSPECT = auto() # Missing derivation or evidence HIGHLY_SUSPECT = auto() # Circular or thermodynamically impossible REJECTED = auto() # Falsified or invalid class ClaimType(Enum): """Types of claims in the framework.""" MATHEMATICAL = auto() # Equations, theorems EMPIRICAL = auto() # Experimental observations THEORETICAL = auto() # Physical theories COMPUTATIONAL = auto() # Simulation results PHILOSOPHICAL = auto() # Conceptual frameworks @dataclass class ClaimEnvelope: """ Immutable envelope for Research Stack claims. Similar to Relay's Context Envelope but specialized for scientific claims with dependency tracking. """ claim_id: str claim_type: ClaimType status: ClaimStatus version: str timestamp: str content_hash: str dependencies: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) evidence_hashes: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) derivation_chain: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) budget_tokens: int = 0 # Complexity budget (analogy to token limits) signature: Optional[str] = None def to_dict(self) -> Dict: """Serialize to dictionary for signing.""" return { "claim_id": self.claim_id, "claim_type": self.claim_type.name, "status": self.status.name, "version": self.version, "timestamp": self.timestamp, "content_hash": self.content_hash, "dependencies": self.dependencies, "evidence_hashes": self.evidence_hashes, "derivation_chain": self.derivation_chain, "budget_tokens": self.budget_tokens } def compute_hash(self) -> str: """Compute SHA256 hash of envelope content.""" data = json.dumps(self.to_dict(), sort_keys=True) return hashlib.sha256(data.encode()).hexdigest()[:16] def sign(self, secret_key: str) -> None: """Cryptographically sign the envelope.""" data = self.compute_hash() + secret_key self.signature = hashlib.sha256(data.encode()).hexdigest()[:32] @dataclass class ValidationResult: """Result of claim validation.""" is_valid: bool claim_id: str status: ClaimStatus failures: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) warnings: List[str] = field(default_factory=list) derivation_depth: int = 0 circular_path: Optional[List[str]] = None class ResearchStackValidator: """ Validator for Research Stack framework claims. Provides: - Claim registration with dependency tracking - Circular reference detection - Derivation chain validation - Budget enforcement (complexity limits) - Immutable ledger of claim evolution """ def __init__(self, framework_version: str, target_standard: str = "6.5sigma"): self.framework_version = framework_version self.target_standard = target_standard self.claims: Dict[str, ClaimEnvelope] = {} self.ledger: List[ClaimEnvelope] = [] self.dependency_graph: Dict[str, Set[str]] = {} self.secret_key = f"research-stack-{framework_version}" # Pre-populate with known framework structure self._bootstrap_framework() def _bootstrap_framework(self) -> None: """Initialize with known Research Stack structure.""" # F01-F12 foundation equations (awaiting derivation) for i in range(1, 13): claim_id = f"F{i:02d}-FoundationKernel" self.register_claim( claim_id=claim_id, claim_type=ClaimType.MATHEMATICAL, content=f"Foundation kernel F{i:02d} (awaiting formal derivation)", dependencies=[], # F01-F12 are axiomatic status=ClaimStatus.PROPOSED ) # Known suspect claims (from adversarial archive) self.register_claim( claim_id="HARMON-CONSTANT", claim_type=ClaimType.EMPIRICAL, content="300% metabolic velocity via boundary layer scouring", dependencies=[], status=ClaimStatus.HIGHLY_SUSPECT, evidence_paths=["6-Documentation/Adversarial Data/README.md"] ) def register_claim( self, claim_id: str, claim_type: ClaimType, content: str, dependencies: List[str] = None, evidence_paths: List[str] = None, status: ClaimStatus = ClaimStatus.PROPOSED, budget_tokens: int = 100 ) -> ClaimEnvelope: """ Register a new claim in the framework. Args: claim_id: Unique identifier (e.g., "F03-BindingHierarchy") claim_type: Type of claim (mathematical, empirical, etc.) content: Description of the claim dependencies: List of claim_ids this claim depends on evidence_paths: File paths to supporting evidence status: Initial validation status budget_tokens: Complexity budget (higher = more complex claim) """ dependencies = dependencies or [] evidence_paths = evidence_paths or [] # Compute content hash content_hash = hashlib.sha256(content.encode()).hexdigest()[:16] # Compute evidence hashes evidence_hashes = [] for path in evidence_paths: if Path(path).exists(): with open(path, 'rb') as f: evidence_hashes.append(hashlib.sha256(f.read()).hexdigest()[:16]) else: evidence_hashes.append(f"missing:{path}") # Create envelope envelope = ClaimEnvelope( claim_id=claim_id, claim_type=claim_type, status=status, version=self.framework_version, timestamp=datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(), content_hash=content_hash, dependencies=dependencies, evidence_hashes=evidence_hashes, budget_tokens=budget_tokens ) # Sign envelope envelope.sign(self.secret_key) # Register claim self.claims[claim_id] = envelope self.dependency_graph[claim_id] = set(dependencies) self.ledger.append(envelope) return envelope def detect_circular_dependencies(self, claim_id: str) -> Optional[List[str]]: """ Detect circular dependency chains. Returns: List of claim_ids forming circular path, or None if acyclic. """ visited = set() rec_stack = set() path = [] def dfs(node: str) -> Optional[List[str]]: visited.add(node) rec_stack.add(node) path.append(node) for neighbor in self.dependency_graph.get(node, set()): if neighbor not in visited: result = dfs(neighbor) if result: return result elif neighbor in rec_stack: # Found cycle cycle_start = path.index(neighbor) return path[cycle_start:] path.pop() rec_stack.remove(node) return None return dfs(claim_id) def validate_chain(self, claim_id: str, max_depth: int = 10) -> ValidationResult: """ Validate complete derivation chain for a claim. Checks: 1. All dependencies exist 2. No circular references 3. Status compatibility (cannot build on SUSPECT claims) 4. Derivation depth within limits 5. Evidence integrity (hashes match) """ result = ValidationResult( is_valid=True, claim_id=claim_id, status=ClaimStatus.PROPOSED, failures=[], warnings=[], derivation_depth=0 ) if claim_id not in self.claims: result.is_valid = False result.failures.append(f"Claim {claim_id} not registered") return result claim = self.claims[claim_id] result.status = claim.status # Check for circular dependencies circular = self.detect_circular_dependencies(claim_id) if circular: result.is_valid = False result.failures.append(f"Circular dependency detected: {' -> '.join(circular)}") result.circular_path = circular return result # Validate all dependencies visited = set() def validate_deps(node: str, depth: int) -> None: if depth > max_depth: result.warnings.append(f"Max derivation depth ({max_depth}) exceeded at {node}") return if node in visited: return visited.add(node) result.derivation_depth = max(result.derivation_depth, depth) if node not in self.claims: result.is_valid = False result.failures.append(f"Missing dependency: {node}") return dep_claim = self.claims[node] # Cannot build on suspect claims if dep_claim.status in [ClaimStatus.SUSPECT, ClaimStatus.HIGHLY_SUSPECT]: result.warnings.append(f"Depends on suspect claim: {node}") if dep_claim.status == ClaimStatus.REJECTED: result.is_valid = False result.failures.append(f"Depends on rejected claim: {node}") # Recursively validate dependencies for dep in dep_claim.dependencies: validate_deps(dep, depth + 1) for dep in claim.dependencies: validate_deps(dep, 1) return result def get_framework_status(self) -> Dict[str, int]: """Get summary of all claims by status.""" status_counts = {status.name: 0 for status in ClaimStatus} for claim in self.claims.values(): status_counts[claim.status.name] += 1 return status_counts def export_ledger(self, path: str) -> None: """Export immutable ledger to JSON file.""" data = { "framework_version": self.framework_version, "target_standard": self.target_standard, "export_time": datetime.now(timezone.utc).isoformat(), "claims": [claim.to_dict() for claim in self.ledger] } with open(path, 'w') as f: json.dump(data, f, indent=2) def find_unproven_claims(self) -> List[str]: """Find all claims awaiting derivation or validation.""" unproven = [] for claim_id, claim in self.claims.items(): if claim.status in [ClaimStatus.PROPOSED, ClaimStatus.DERIVED]: # Check if it has complete derivation chain result = self.validate_chain(claim_id) if result.derivation_depth < 2: # Shallow derivation unproven.append(claim_id) return unproven # Example usage and validation if __name__ == "__main__": # Initialize validator validator = ResearchStackValidator( framework_version="2026-05-06", target_standard="6.5sigma" ) # Register some biological framework claims validator.register_claim( claim_id="Cancer-CompressionFailure", claim_type=ClaimType.THEORETICAL, content="Cancer as information corruption in robust compression", dependencies=["F02-ConstraintGeneration", "F08-RobustnessCompression"], evidence_paths=[ "6-Documentation/docs/speculative-materials/CancerAsCompressionFailure.md" ], status=ClaimStatus.DERIVED ) validator.register_claim( claim_id="Semelparity-ControlledDecompression", claim_type=ClaimType.THEORETICAL, content="Semelparity as programmed decompression vs cancer corruption", dependencies=["Cancer-CompressionFailure", "F09-CompressionDynamics"], status=ClaimStatus.DERIVED ) # Test validation result = validator.validate_chain("Semelparity-ControlledDecompression") print(f"Validation result for Semelparity claim:") print(f" Valid: {result.is_valid}") print(f" Status: {result.status.name}") print(f" Derivation depth: {result.derivation_depth}") print(f" Warnings: {result.warnings}") # Check framework status status = validator.get_framework_status() print(f"\nFramework status:") for status_name, count in status.items(): if count > 0: print(f" {status_name}: {count}") # Find unproven claims unproven = validator.find_unproven_claims() print(f"\nUnproven claims awaiting derivation: {unproven}") # Export ledger validator.export_ledger("/tmp/research_stack_ledger.json") print(f"\nLedger exported to /tmp/research_stack_ledger.json")