diff --git a/formal/SilverSight/GCCL.lean b/formal/SilverSight/GCCL.lean index fc8695ab..410da33d 100644 --- a/formal/SilverSight/GCCL.lean +++ b/formal/SilverSight/GCCL.lean @@ -249,6 +249,181 @@ theorem lawful_all_pass (t : Transition) : t.decision = Decision.accept := by simp [isLawful] +/-! §8b The Five Control Filters (Admit Pipeline) + + The GCCL gate decomposes into eight sub-checks, organized as the + five canonical control filters plus three bookkeeping gates. + + These began as meme-named handles on real mathematical machinery + (see "Meme Math That Pays Rent"). The jokes got parking passes; + they pay rent as formal admission gates. + + Timeline of the COUCH family: + + COUCH — "Super Freak" / Rick James / moving sofa problem + The original. A continuous oscillator with a joke name, formalized + as a Lean witness with 5 regimes and 28 theorems. Measures pressure + and hysteresis stability. The "apartment constraint" (x_i(t) ∈ Ω) + is the moving sofa problem: a legitimate unsolved math problem + (2.2195 ≤ S ≤ 2.8284). Rick James said "I'm in the apartment, not + touching the walls." That IS the constrained-manifold traversal. + + Fuck Your Couch (FYC) — the punchline, reformed into a gate + "I'm Rick James, bitch!" → deprecated as formal name → reformed into + FYC Gate: rejects impossible constrained-manifold traversal. A + candidate route that claims it can navigate a topology that's + actually impossible gets rejected. + + LoC/NES Monster — "Loch Ness Monster" + Locality-of-change check. Detects entropy smuggling via recurrence. + Wraps the set with a creature-feature theme. + + Tree Fiddy — "I need about tree fiddy" + Cost bound. The budget beyond which the Loch Ness Monster takes your + money. Checks that the AngrySphinx cost (2^depth) is within budget. + + BHOCS — "Big Hash of Certified Stuff" + Receipt/audit trail verification. The SHA-256 hash chain is intact. + + Philosophy: "A joke can get a parking pass. It does not get tenure. + If it wants to stay in the stack, it has to pay rent." + + The memes are brightly colored handles on machinery that would + otherwise be too abstract to remember — but underneath, it's a + serious admission gate. + + Connection to GCCL law axes: + replay_valid → Compression (round-trip) + byte_gain > 0 → Compression (actual reduction) + residual_declared → Residual (explicit loss) + LoC_NES_pass → Cognitive (locality, no smuggling) + FYC_pass → Geometric (traversable manifold) + COUCH_stable → Geometric (pressure stability) + TreeFiddy_bounded → Cost (budget) + BHOCS_verified → Receipt (audit trail) +-/ + +/-- A candidate transition X entering the admission pipeline. -/ +structure CandidateX where + /-- Replay produces identical output (determinism) -/ + replayValid : Bool + /-- Net byte reduction > 0 (actual compression) -/ + byteGain : Q16_16 -- positive means compression achieved + /-- Residual (loss) is explicitly declared, not hidden -/ + residualDeclared : Bool + /-- Locality-of-change: no entropy smuggling via recurrence -/ + locNesPass : Bool + /-- FYC: constrained-manifold traversal is geometrically possible -/ + fycPass : Bool + /-- COUCH: pressure/hysteresis stability (the original gate) -/ + couchStable : Bool + /-- Tree Fiddy: cost within budget (AngrySphinx 2^depth ≤ limit) -/ + treeFiddyBounded : Bool + /-- BHOCS: receipt/audit trail (SHA-256 hash chain) verified -/ + bhocsVerified : Bool + deriving Repr, DecidableEq, Inhabited + +/-- byteGain > 0 check: actual compression was achieved. -/ +def byteGainPositive (x : CandidateX) : Bool := + x.byteGain > Q16_16.zero + +/-- The full Admit predicate — all eight gates must pass. + + Admit(X) = replay_valid(X) + ∧ byte_gain(X) > 0 + ∧ residual_declared(X) + ∧ LoC_NES_pass(X) + ∧ FYC_pass(X) + ∧ COUCH_stable(X) + ∧ TreeFiddy_bounded(X) + ∧ BHOCS_verified(X) + + A candidate is admitted only if it survives all five control filters + plus the three bookkeeping gates. Each gate checks a different aspect + of lawfulness: + + - replay_valid: the encoding is deterministic and reproducible + - byte_gain > 0: the candidate actually compresses (fewer collisions) + - residual_declared: the quantization loss is explicit (Q16_16 floor) + - LoC_NES_pass: locality of change (no rewriting the entire tree) + - FYC_pass: the braid structure is geometrically traversable + - COUCH_stable: the candidate's Omega is in the stable range + - TreeFiddy_bounded: AngrySphinx cost 2^depth ≤ budget + - BHOCS_verified: the SHA-256 hash chain is intact -/ +def Admit (x : CandidateX) : Bool := + x.replayValid && + byteGainPositive x && + x.residualDeclared && + x.locNesPass && + x.fycPass && + x.couchStable && + x.treeFiddyBounded && + x.bhocsVerified + +/-- Admit requires ALL eight gates to pass. -/ +theorem admit_all_pass (x : CandidateX) : + Admit x ↔ + x.replayValid ∧ + byteGainPositive x ∧ + x.residualDeclared ∧ + x.locNesPass ∧ + x.fycPass ∧ + x.couchStable ∧ + x.treeFiddyBounded ∧ + x.bhocsVerified := by + simp [Admit] + +/-- A candidate with any gate failing is NOT admitted. -/ +theorem admit_fails_on_any_failure (x : CandidateX) : + (¬ x.replayValid ∨ ¬ byteGainPositive x ∨ ¬ x.residualDeclared ∨ + ¬ x.locNesPass ∨ ¬ x.fycPass ∨ ¬ x.couchStable ∨ + ¬ x.treeFiddyBounded ∨ ¬ x.bhocsVerified) → + ¬ Admit x := by + intro h + by_contra hAdmit + rw [admit_all_pass] at hAdmit + obtain ⟨h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, h6, h7, h8⟩ := hAdmit + rcases h with h1' | h2' | h3' | h4' | h5' | h6' | h7' | h8' + · exact h1' h1 + · exact h2' h2 + · exact h3' h3 + · exact h4' h4 + · exact h5' h5 + · exact h6' h6 + · exact h7' h7 + · exact h8' h8 + +/-- FYC rejects impossible constrained-manifold traversal. + + If FYC_pass is false, the candidate is rejected regardless of + other gates. A route that claims to navigate an impossible + topology cannot be admitted. -/ +theorem fyc_rejection_blocks_admit (x : CandidateX) (h : ¬ x.fycPass) : + ¬ Admit x := by + intro hAdmit + rw [admit_all_pass] at hAdmit + exact h hAdmit.2.2.2.1 + +/-- Tree Fiddy bounds the AngrySphinx cost. + + If the cost exceeds the Tree Fiddy budget, the candidate is rejected. + The Loch Ness Monster takes your money. -/ +theorem treeFiddy_rejection_blocks_admit (x : CandidateX) (h : ¬ x.treeFiddyBounded) : + ¬ Admit x := by + intro hAdmit + rw [admit_all_pass] at hAdmit + exact h hAdmit.2.2.2.2.1 + +/-- A fully-passing candidate IS admitted. -/ +theorem all_pass_implies_admit (x : CandidateX) + (h1 : x.replayValid) (h2 : byteGainPositive x) + (h3 : x.residualDeclared) (h4 : x.locNesPass) + (h5 : x.fycPass) (h6 : x.couchStable) + (h7 : x.treeFiddyBounded) (h8 : x.bhocsVerified) : + Admit x := by + rw [admit_all_pass] + exact ⟨h1, h2, h3, h4, h5, h6, h7, h8⟩ + /-! §9 GCCL Swap Gate (Q16_16) -/ /-- GCCL swap decision result. -/