diff --git a/docs/living/DIRECTION_LOG.md b/docs/living/DIRECTION_LOG.md index 8d101613..819a3e1d 100644 --- a/docs/living/DIRECTION_LOG.md +++ b/docs/living/DIRECTION_LOG.md @@ -73,3 +73,41 @@ embedding that makes nonlinear properties spectrally detectable. **Why:** Braille/T9 on text: 4.167 b/B (dead). But the p-adic valuations (prime factorization) ARE the prime decomposition — the invariant signature. DNA carries invariants, not compressed bytes. + +## 2026-07-03: Prime-Sidon Hypothesis → Honest Negative + +**Was:** The prime number distribution has a Sidon-related spectral +signature detectable via Perceval SLOS. + +**Result:** Honest negative. 35 test cases, 0/35 significant after +Bonferroni correction. The adversarial review caught a tautology +in the original methodology (which would have produced false +positives), added the null hypothesis, and the negative finding +is properly bounded. + +**What this means:** The prime distribution does NOT have a +Sidon-detectable spectral signature through the SLOS pipeline. +This is a measured negative — it clears the question off the board. + +**Recorded in:** +- ENE database: session prime-sidon-negative-001 (promoted) +- ENE packages: prime-sidon-pkg-001 (verified, promoted) +- ENE receipts: negative_result (verified) +- ENE ingest_events: prime-ingest-001 (recorded) +- GitHub: commit a0d95049 + +**Implication for the octagon:** primes don't have the spectral +signature that Sidon sets do. The octagon works for Sidon (4/4) +but NOT for primes (0/35). This is a third data point: + +| Problem | Octagon works? | Evidence | +|---------|----------------|----------| +| Sidon sets | YES | 4/4 (measured) | +| Graph coloring | YES | Hoffman bound (known) | +| Prime distribution | NO | 0/35 after Bonferroni (measured) | +| Graph isomorphism | NO | Cospectral graphs (known) | +| Text | NO | 3.088 b/B (measured) | + +The octagon is NOT universal. It works for some problems and +fails for others. The research question is now: what determines +which problems have spectral signatures? diff --git a/docs/living/TARGETS.md b/docs/living/TARGETS.md index 64cf2787..ecf0f515 100644 --- a/docs/living/TARGETS.md +++ b/docs/living/TARGETS.md @@ -96,3 +96,11 @@ is the P vs NP experimental program's first NP-complete test case. with eigenvalue product computation (O(n^m)). Only works for linear systems. Needs: verify eigenvalue products match SLOS output on the Sidon crossing matrix. + +## ~~Prime-Sidon spectral detection~~ [DEAD — 2026-07-03] + +**Result:** Honest negative. 35 test cases, 0/35 significant after +Bonferroni. The prime distribution does NOT have a Sidon-detectable +spectral signature through SLOS. Adversarial review caught a tautology +in the original methodology, null was properly added, negative is +bounded. ENE session: prime-sidon-negative-001 (promoted).