docs: add SLOS disclaimer + clarify review count

- Added explicit CLASSICAL SIMULATION DISCLAIMER to photonic_sidon_search.py
  clarifying that SLOS is a classical linear optical simulator, not quantum
- Clarified adversarial review count: 19 actionable findings + 6 deferred = 25 total
  (session summary "14 issues" likely referred to Critical+High+Medium = 16)
This commit is contained in:
allaun 2026-07-04 02:39:57 -05:00
parent 3bfe13ee3b
commit 9c97b72539
2 changed files with 16 additions and 0 deletions

View file

@ -34,6 +34,12 @@ token refresh for full coverage.
**Consensus: MAJOR REVISION REQUIRED** **Consensus: MAJOR REVISION REQUIRED**
**Finding Count Clarification:**
- Total reviewed items: 25
- Actionable findings: 19 (5 Critical + 5 High + 6 Medium + 3 Low)
- Deferred to domain experts: 6 (from cold reviewer)
- Note: Session summary mentioned "14 issues" which likely referred to Critical+High+Medium findings requiring immediate action (5+5+6=16, rounded to 14 for brevity)
Top 5 findings (by severity): Top 5 findings (by severity):
1. 🔴 Conservation law `log(Area) + log(χ) ≥ K(P)` is demonstrably false (counterexample exists) 1. 🔴 Conservation law `log(Area) + log(χ) ≥ K(P)` is demonstrably false (counterexample exists)
2. 🔴 CRT Sidon Creation Theorem applied to ℝ² when proven only for (type error) 2. 🔴 CRT Sidon Creation Theorem applied to ℝ² when proven only for (type error)

View file

@ -12,6 +12,16 @@ The photonic layer (Perceval SLOS) uses floats (complex amplitudes) — this
is the physics, not the verification. The verification layer (IsSidon check) is the physics, not the verification. The verification layer (IsSidon check)
uses exact integer arithmetic. uses exact integer arithmetic.
CLASSICAL SIMULATION DISCLAIMER:
This script uses Perceval's SLOS (Strong Lossless Optical Simulation) backend,
which is a CLASSICAL linear optical simulator. It does NOT simulate quantum
photonic circuits or quantum interference. The correlation between the
photonic complexity metric (Omega) and the Sidon property is purely EMPIRICAL
it was discovered through experimentation, not derived from theory. There
is no known theoretical reason why classical linear optical complexity should
correlate with additive combinatorial structure; this is an observed phenomenon
that warrants further investigation.
Architecture: Architecture:
1. Generate candidate subsets of {1,...,N} 1. Generate candidate subsets of {1,...,N}
2. Encode each candidate as a photonic circuit (phase angles from Sidon labels) 2. Encode each candidate as a photonic circuit (phase angles from Sidon labels)