diff --git a/AGENTS.md b/AGENTS.md index 93d8f62b..ea7c7a0a 100644 --- a/AGENTS.md +++ b/AGENTS.md @@ -437,3 +437,37 @@ All five must pass. If any fails, the commit is quarantined and flagged for huma | 3: CAS/SMT grounding | Vacuous/tautological proofs | SymPy, Z3 | ❌ Missing | | 4: Dual-sided proof | Smuggled quantum assumptions | PennyLane, Biopython | ⚠️ Partial (QUBO exists) | | 5: Claim-state ladder | Unvalidated promotion | Review protocol | ⚠️ Partial (AGENTS.md framework) + +## Post-Stability Refinements + +These refinements should be incorporated after the core braid/eigensolid formalization is stable. They are cross-references and experimental testbeds — not blockers. + +### Turkel et al. TTG — Braid Topology in Twisted Trilayer Graphene + +Turkel et al., *Science* 376, 193 (2022), DOI: 10.1126/science.abk1895. +Supplementary materials at: `supplementary/Turkel2022_TTG_SOM.pdf` (externally sourced) + +**What it demonstrates:** A physical system (3-layer graphene, two independent twist angles θTM, θBM) that undergoes a Moiré Lattice Reconstruction (MLR) producing exactly three discrete topological defect classes — plaquettes, solitons, and twistons — organized in a honeycomb network at the moiré-of-moiré scale Λ. This is a braid-word structure in a real material. + +**Mapping to our formalism:** + +| TTG physical quantity | Our braid formalism | +|---|---| +| θTM, θBM (twist angles) | `BraidStateN 3` inter-strand crossing parameters | +| MLR → AtA domains (no AtB) | Eigensolid convergence: `crossStep(s) = s` | +| Λ = a/δθ (moiré of moiré) | Sidon slack / braid word period | +| Plaquette (1.45°) / soliton (1.54°) / twiston (1.68°) | Scar types: stable / soliton / topological defect | +| GSFE energy functional (Eq. S4) | Q16_16 crossing energy (Φ_couch_to_fourier) | +| Relaxation displacement u_ℓ (Eq. S2) | Strand jitter + residue fields | +| Flat band resonance at ν~±2.4 | ∅_scars (scar absence → FAMM gate pass) | +| Disorder reduction at resonance doping | Eigensolid fixed point → uniform LDOS | +| Hartree-Fock correction (4 meV → 19 meV width) | Crossing energy renormalization (many-body → Q16_16) | +| Heterostrain ε_x on solitons (C3 breaking) | Braid word defect: non-trivial braid group element | + +**Key insight for formalization:** The MLR does *not* distribute twist-angle error as random noise — it bifurcates into discrete topological classes. This is exactly what a braid representation (Artin B_n) predicts: twist mismatch is absorbed as a word in the braid group, not as a continuous random field. The triple-domain structure is a braid word with exactly 3 defect letters. + +**When to apply:** +- After `BraidStateN.lean` and `SpectralN.lean` are stable and proven +- As a test case for n=3 (current work fixes n=8; TTG provides a natural n=3 physical instance) +- The GSFE parameterization (Eq. S4) can be ported as a specific instance of our generalized stacking-fault energy functional +- The Hartree-Fock vs single-particle comparison validates our requirement for interaction-aware crossing energy (no single-particle model reproduces the 19 meV VHS width correctly)