openresearch
|
2f0328602f
|
fix: agent-reviewed Lean fixes + reorganize rejected theories
Three agents reviewed and repaired:
1. CacheSieve.lean (7 errors fixed):
- Rewrote shouldAdmit (removed head!/match, both branches were true)
- Fixed evictVictim type mismatch (Option CacheLine → Option ℕ)
- Removed sorry from evict_prefers_reset (proved properly)
- Removed excess omega calls (simp already closed goals)
2. HCMR.lean (3 errors fixed):
- Removed excess omega after simp (no goals to solve)
- Downgraded ring_fastest_subleq_avx from > to ≥ (theorem was FALSE
for baseRate=1 due to integer truncation: 0 > 0 fails)
- Used Nat.div_le_div_right instead of omega (nonlinear division)
3. Blitter6502OISC.lean (2 issues fixed):
- Removed redundant rw [if_pos rfl] (simp already closed)
- Downgraded ring_faster_than_subleq_blitter from > to ≥
4. CRTSidonN.lean (2 issues fixed):
- Fixed wrong lemma name (Nat.sub_le_sub_left → direct omega)
- Replaced nlinarith with Nat.mul_le_mul_left
5. YangMillsPerformance.lean: 1 sorry flagged (compression_overhead_bounded)
nlinarith-on-division fragility flagged but not fixed
6. WorkloadTestbench.lean: depends on CacheSieve (now fixed)
excess omega flagged but not fixed
Reorganized docs:
- 7 rejected theory docs moved to docs/research/failed/
(dual quaternion, chiral batch, BraidStorm×TreeBraid×COUCH,
HCMR multiplexer, spherical chiral, QUBO/QAOA, rendering equation)
- Each has STATUS: REJECTED header with reason and receipt
- failed/README.md created with inventory
- SIX_STAGE_SEARCH_ENGINE.md: added C3-kill note
Rejected because:
- Dual quaternion algebra wrong (integers ≠ unit quaternions)
- Chiral discrimination of Sidon FALSE (C3: position-invariant)
- 'Degree on S²' invented (Rossby drift is scalar sum)
- QUBO/QAOA bridge entirely speculative
- Rendering equation analogy not theorem
- 'n/2 channels' is renamed Sidon, not new
|
2026-07-04 22:28:09 +00:00 |
|