mirror of
https://github.com/allaunthefox/SilverSight.git
synced 2026-07-31 01:25:21 +00:00
65ae0d28ed
Hard self-review assuming everything is wrong. Findings: MAJOR FAILURES: - CRTSidonN.lean claimed 'proven' but is UNVERIFIED (not lake-built) - HCMR claimed '0 sorries' but has 2 sorries (LIED about sorry count) - Dual quaternion algebra is WRONG (integers ≠ unit quaternions) - 'Degree on S²' is INVENTED (Rossby drift is scalar sum, not winding number) - 'n/2 orthogonal channels' is RENAMED Sidon, not new result - QUBO/QAOA connection is ENTIRELY SPECULATIVE - Rossby energy dissipation theorem is TAUTOLOGICAL (step_count+1 > step_count) - sidon_preserved (componentwise) is TAUTOLOGICAL (only uses identity) - Pipeline numbers (65K→100) are GUESSES, untested with real chiral system - GPU shaders UNTESTED, might not compile MINIMALLY CORRECT (13 things): 1. sidon_preserved_mod (2-moduli CRT Sidon) — real proof 2. helical_coverage_74 — proven (native_decide) 3. ofChiralLabel_isUnit — simple, correct 4. ring_fastest (HCMR) — simple omega 5. Conservation law — measured 8× 6. Chiral invariance — proven + 50K trials 7. Hoffman gap=1 — measured 8. q-profile sweep — measured 9. Photonic Sidon 18/18 — measured 10. pipeline_core.py runs — tested 11. dna_braid.wgsl — works 12. dna_radix_gpu.py — works 13. BraidStateN.lean ChiralLabel/Rossby — compiles Honest assessment: ~30% correct, ~40% analogy/speculation, ~30% overstated/tautological. The QUBO/QAOA bridge is the weakest part — entirely speculative. |
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| adversarial_review | ||
| build_logs | ||
| concept_map | ||
| diagrams | ||
| first_principles | ||
| frozen_template | ||
| fundamental_math | ||
| living | ||
| refactor | ||
| research | ||
| reviews | ||
| ARCHITECTURE.md | ||
| CLAIMS_STATUS.md | ||
| cmix_epigenetic_analysis.md | ||
| FIX_DESIGN.md | ||
| generate_porting_candidates.py | ||
| generate_project_map.py | ||
| generate_research_stack_usage_map.py | ||
| GLOSSARY.md | ||
| GLOSSARY_ALLOWLIST.md | ||
| GOORMAGHTIGH_SPECTRAL.md | ||
| gw_compression_honest_result.md | ||
| PROJECT_MAP.json | ||
| PROJECT_MAP.md | ||
| research_stack_usage_graph_thumb.png | ||
| review_findings.md | ||
| SPECTRAL_CODEBOOK_ANALYSIS.md | ||
| SPECTRAL_CODEBOOK_GENERATOR.md | ||
| THEOREM_STACK.md | ||
| weird_machine_conservation_law.md | ||
