Whitespace-only polish of solution.tex: 46 chktex warnings fixed
- W2 (43x): 'word \eqref{...}' -> 'word~\eqref{...}' and continuation-line
joins so references stay glued to their prose
- W24 (3x): \label glued to the \begin{...} line
- W8 kept (5x, all in the DOI identifier 10.1090/S0025-5718-1965-0194620-7:
single hyphens are correct there, not prose dashes)
Verified: chktex W2+W24 = 0 (total 128, all W3/W25 brace suggestions + W8
DOI false positives); pdflatex 3-pass clean build (0 errors, 0 warnings,
0 overfull, 17 pages, 0 '??'); token-level PDF text diff vs the shipped
e85d7bf9 PDF shows only glyph-extraction/wrap artifacts (content identical,
whitespace-only tex diff).
NOTE: this is the parallel audited line (
|
||
|---|---|---|
| .. | ||
| certificates | ||
| ADVERSARIAL_AUDIT.md | ||
| ADVERSARIAL_REVIEW_AGAINST_CHALLENGE_RULES.md | ||
| HOW_THE_SOLUTION_WAS_FOUND.md | ||
| NOTATION_AND_BORROWED_TERMINOLOGY.md | ||
| ramanujan_challenge_problem_2_8.zip | ||
| README.md | ||
| RELEASE_SHA256.txt | ||
| run_checks.sh | ||
| solution.pdf | ||
| solution.tex | ||
Ramanujan Challenge, Problem 2.8
This package proves, for each of the four official columns,
[ \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{P_{N,j}}{Q_{N,j}} =\frac{\sqrt{10005}}{\pi}, \qquad \lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{Q_{N,j}}{P_{N,j}} =\frac{\pi}{\sqrt{10005}}. ]
The first display is the orientation requested in Problem 2.8; the second is its reciprocal consequence.
Contents
solution.pdf— the complete proof.solution.tex— its LaTeX source.certificates/p28_standalone_equations.py— mandatory, dependency-free expansion of the four cleared Ore identities, tail coefficient equations, terminating base/generic/top identities, ascension, and the hypergeometric differential equation. It uses rational coefficient dictionaries only: no division algorithm, simplifier, factorizer, special function library, root finder, or sample values.certificates/p28_dominant_product_algebra.py— mandatory, dependency-free verification of the balanced limit, characteristic polynomial, root-separation inequalities, left-eigenvector identity, and four positive-coordinate rewrites.certificates/STANDALONE_EQUATION_CERTIFICATES.md— the same Ore and terminating identities in a human-readable, denominator-cleared equation sheet.certificates/p28_full_closure_certificate.wl— optional independent symbolic cross-check of the differential gauge and closure.certificates/p28_full_closure_certificate.PASS.txt— transcript of a stateless Wolfram Language run (22 exact checks plus the consolidated conclusion).certificates/p28_convergence_constants.pyandcertificates/p28_rank_ode_bound_verifier.py— dependency-free exact rational checks for the fixed-point convergence bound.certificates/p28_kernel_contiguity_certificate.sage,certificates/p28_lattice_hypotheses_certificate.sage, andcertificates/all_four_columns_certificate.sage— independent exact SageMath cross-checks.certificates/p28_parametric_pade_probe.py— finite exact regression, included as a diagnostic only and not used as proof.ADVERSARIAL_AUDIT.md— defect ledger, repairs, replay evidence, and the exact trust boundary.
Reproduction
From this directory, run:
./run_checks.sh
The mandatory proof path is Python-standard-library only. The Wolfram cross-check can also be run directly:
wolframscript -file certificates/p28_full_closure_certificate.wl
The Python checks use only the standard library:
python3 certificates/p28_rank_ode_bound_verifier.py
python3 certificates/p28_convergence_constants.py
python3 certificates/p28_standalone_equations.py
python3 certificates/p28_dominant_product_algebra.py
For the independent SageMath checks:
sage certificates/p28_kernel_contiguity_certificate.sage
sage certificates/p28_lattice_hypotheses_certificate.sage
sage certificates/all_four_columns_certificate.sage
To rebuild the manuscript:
latexmk -pdf solution.tex
Trust boundary
No numerical enclosure is used to infer equality. The recurrence proof is
expanded into explicit equations and an elementary stable-graph contraction.
The sole imported mathematical theorem is the classical Chudnovsky formula,
identified precisely in solution.tex with a reference to a complete
modular/CM derivation. Thus the package is self-contained relative to that
published theorem; it does not claim to reconstruct the entire theory of the
Chudnovsky formula from first principles.