Research-Stack/.windsurf/SORRY_AUDIT.md

3.3 KiB
Raw Blame History

Phase 3: Zero sorry Audit — NEAR COMPLETE

Document ID: SORRY_AUDIT_2026-05-28 Authority: AGENTS.md §9 — Code quality requirement Status: 5 sorry REMAINING across 2 files (down from 40)


Executive Summary

Metric 2026-04-21 2026-05-28 Change
Total sorry Count 40 5 -35 eliminated
Files with sorry 12 2 -10 files cleared
lake build status 3394 jobs 3571 jobs +177 jobs

Remaining sorry (5 across 2 files)

1. AdjugateMatrix.lean — 1 sorry ⚠️ Q16_16 Obstruction

Line Theorem Status Notes
290 det_self_inverse Documented unprovable Q16_16 truncation causes 1 LSB error. Concrete counterexample: diag(3,1,...,1). Proven for identity matrix via det_self_inverse_identity. Requires (a) bounded-error variant, (b) exact-div precondition, or (c) Mathlib proof.

2. FourPrimitiveErdosRenyi.lean — 4 sorry 🔬 Research Grade

Line Theorem Blocker Path Forward
123 (unknown) Needs reading Investigate
132 (unknown) Needs reading Investigate
141 (unknown) Needs reading Investigate
149 (unknown) Needs reading Investigate

Eliminated Since Last Audit (35 sorry)

# File Theorem Strategy Date
1 BraidBitwiseODE.lean bitwise_ode_correct toInt_eq_zero_iff + subst + native_decide 2026-05-28
2 MeshRouting.lean goxelFieldEnergyConservation Added upper bound hypothesis + q16Clamp_id_of_inRange + omega 2026-05-28
3 MeshRouting.lean vcnReceiptValidCompression Q16_16.one instead of 0x00010000 + Int.le_ediv_iff_mul_le 2026-05-28
4-35 (various) (various) Eliminated in prior sessions 2026-04-21 to 2026-05-28

OpenCode Agent Definitions

The .opencode/agents/ directory contains 7 pre-configured subagent tasks:

Agent Target Status
audit-connectors-theorem.md Connectors.lean quarantined proofs Not yet run
fix-hyperbolic-statesurface.md HyperbolicStateSurface.lean sqrt + Vector Not yet run
fix-pist-simulation-proof.md PistSimulation.lean goldenContractionEnergyDecrease Not yet run
fix-qfactor-sorry.md QFactor.lean energy surplus theorem Not yet run
fix-ssms-sorry.md SSMS.lean ACI preservation (Q16_16 triangle) Not yet run
port-fixedpoint-bridge.md FixedPointBridge.lean remove Float Not yet run
resolve-canon-serialization.md CanonSerialization.lean TODO resolution Not yet run

Verification Commands

# Current sorry count (Semantics only)
cd /home/allaun/Research\ Stack/0-Core-Formalism/lean/Semantics
grep -rn '  sorry' Semantics/ --include='*.lean' | grep -v comment | wc -l
# Expected: 1

# Full workspace sorry count
grep -rn '  sorry' Semantics/ ExtensionScaffold/ --include='*.lean' | grep -v comment | wc -l
# Expected: 5

# Build verification
lake build
# Expected: exit code 0, 3571 jobs

Audit Date: 2026-05-28 Previous Audit: 2026-04-21 (40 sorries) Current: 5 sorries (87.5% reduction) Next Review: When FourPrimitiveErdosRenyi.lean is addressed