allaun/Research-Stack
1
0
Fork 0
mirror of https://github.com/allaunthefox/Research-Stack.git synced 2026-07-30 18:56:16 +00:00
Code Issues Projects Releases Packages Wiki Activity Actions 1
Research-Stack/6-Documentation/docs/geometric-substance/ARCHIVE_SUPERSEDED.md
allaunthefox f4cbbb9873 docs(geometric-substance): canonical reconciliation + gravity-consistency gate 
Single reconciled vocabulary and conceptual frame, superseding scattered
revisions; super-Cartan demoted to a gated extension module (off by default).

- GEOMETRIC_SUBSTANCE_CANONICAL.md: C^8/J Cartan substance, observer/observerless
  (typed projection Pi), Sidon inexact-mirror, vocabulary lock (by mechanism),
  mechanism->port-role map, Dolbeault-Laplacian resolution, evidence tiers.
- Gravity-consistency gate (sec 7): R_ij != 0 AND identified curvature class;
  shown to coincide with the differential "something rather than nothing" test.
  Initial recovery (provisional, RESIDUAL_TESTED): achiral -> teleparallel
  (curvature ~0), chiral -> Einstein-Cartan, Sidon separates from random at ~4sigma.
  Seven stress-tests listed before promotion.
- gate_residual_recovery.py: the computation (prototype residual, not the Lean codec).
- ARCHIVE_SUPERSEDED.md + archive_superseded.sh: read-only archival index and a
  non-destructive (git mv + banner) move script for superseded vocabulary docs.
2026-06-27 06:38:55 +00:00

4.7 KiB
Raw Blame History

ARCHIVE — Superseded Documentation (READ ONLY)

READ-ONLY / HISTORICAL. Everything indexed here is superseded by GEOMETRIC_SUBSTANCE_CANONICAL.md (2026-06). It is retained only for traceability — to show where a term or framing came from across earlier conceptual revisions. Do not use anything below as current doctrine.

The canonical document reconciled the forked vocabulary by mechanism. The definitions recorded here are the prior, conflicting versions it replaced.

A. Quarantined now — canonical owns their entire purpose

These docs exist solely to define vocabulary / name concepts that the canonical document now defines better. They are moved to 6-Documentation/docs/_superseded/2026-06/ by archive_superseded.sh, each with a read-only banner prepended.

Archived doc What it asserted (now superseded) Replaced by
6-Documentation/docs/VOCABULARY_LOCK.md DIAT = "Dynamic Integer-Address Transform"; NUVMAP = "Non-Uniform Variable Mapping (2D spectral projection)" → Semantics.NUVMATH; PIST = "Perfectly Imperfect Square Theory" Canonical §4 (the new lock), §1
0-Core-Formalism/otom/docs/nuvmap/NUVMAP_NAMING_AND_DEFINITION.md NUVMAP = "Non-Uniform Virtual Memory Address Projection" Canonical §4 (NUVMAP + PhiNUVMAP entries)

Why these and not the Lean files: the implementation (.lean) is the source of truth and stays put. Only the naming/lock docs — whose grasp the canonical reconciliation has fully absorbed — are quarantined.

B. Review candidates — mixed content, your call

Each of these carries some superseded vocabulary plus content that may still be live (engineering guidance, other notation, dated records). Archiving the whole file would bury the still-good parts, so they are not auto-quarantined. Recommendation per doc below; enable any of them in archive_superseded.sh once confirmed, or update the stale rows in place instead.

Candidate doc Stale element Recommendation
0-Core-Formalism/otom/docs/wiki/NotationNomenclatureRegistry.md DIAT = "Dual-Interval Algebraic Transform"; NUVMAP = "spectral pixel/state container" Broad registry — update the two rows in place, point them at canonical §4; do not archive wholesale
6-Documentation/docs/WEIRD_CONCEPTS_GLOSSARY.md Defines the "weird concepts" the canonical doc reconciled and tiered Likely superseded for the reconciled terms — read and confirm, then archive or update
6-Documentation/docs/GLOSSARY.md, 6-Documentation/wiki/Glossary.md, obsidian-vault/00-MAP/Glossary.md Carry old DIAT/NUVMAP/PIST entries Glossaries with many entries — update the affected entries, don't archive
0-Core-Formalism/otom/docs/nuvmap/NUVMAP_DESIGN_REFLECTIONS.md Uses superseded NUVMAP naming Naming is stale but the design reasoning may be live — read before deciding
0-Core-Formalism/otom/docs/nuvmap/NUVMAP_ENCODING_DOS_AND_DONTS.md Uses superseded NUVMAP naming Engineering dos/don'ts may still hold — keep unless content is obsolete
6-Documentation/docs/semantics/BHOCS.md, 6-Documentation/docs/semantics/AMMR_NODE_REDEFINITION.md, 6-Documentation/docs/semantics/RG_FLOW_DEFINITION.md Reference reconciled terms Unread here — triage individually
6-Documentation/docs/reports/adaptive_analysis_2026-05-11.md and other dated reports Use old vocabulary Leave as-is — dated reports are point-in-time records, already historical by nature
6-Documentation/wiki/Concept-Archive.md — Leave — already an archive

C. Method

  • Non-destructive. archive_superseded.sh uses git mv + a prepended banner; nothing is deleted, history is preserved, and the content stays readable.
  • Conservative. Only docs whose entire purpose the canonical doc absorbs are quarantined automatically. Mixed-content docs are listed, not buried, because a doc that is 80% live should not be flagged dead over a stale definition.
  • Reversible. git mv back, or strip the banner, restores any file.

Gitignore note. This repo's .gitignore line 120 (**/archive/) ignores every archive/ directory (those are offloaded to Gdrive, line 114). So the archive deliberately uses _superseded/, not archive/, to stay tracked in git as readable read-only history. If you would rather these be offloaded like other archives, point DEST at an archive/ path — the script will warn that the files become untracked.

To run (from the repo root):

bash archive_superseded.sh
git status        # review the moves
git commit -m "Archive vocabulary docs superseded by GEOMETRIC_SUBSTANCE_CANONICAL"